A family’s death triggered panic about contaminated street food in Istanbul, but forensic evidence revealed the real killer was industrial fumigation chemicals.

Quick Take

• A German-Turkish family died on November 12, 2025, after consuming street food in Istanbul’s Ortaköy neighborhood, but forensic experts determined aluminum phosphide from hotel fumigation was the actual cause, not food contamination
• Initial public speculation about contaminated food triggered an 80+ percent sales collapse for street vendors before the correct cause was identified
• Even after forensic clarification, sales remained 40 percent below baseline weeks later, demonstrating how misinformation creates lasting economic damage
• Industry associations demanded public recognition that the sector was unfairly stigmatized and called for policy clarification on hotel fumigation safety protocols

The Speculation That Sparked Economic Collapse

When the family fell ill on November 12 and subsequently died, Istanbul’s food service sector faced an invisible enemy: public perception. The immediate assumption that contaminated street food caused the deaths spread rapidly through media and social channels before forensic analysis could be completed. Street vendors in Beşiktaş experienced sales declines exceeding 80 percent in the immediate aftermath, while kebab and chicken döner shops reported losses up to 25 percent. Online food-delivery orders fell at nearly the same rate. Individual merchants reported turnovers falling by as much as 70 percent.

Watch:

When Forensic Evidence Arrived Too Late

Forensic experts eventually determined that aluminum phosphide from hotel fumigation—not food contamination—caused the family’s deaths. This finding fundamentally reframed the incident from a food safety crisis to an occupational and environmental safety issue. However, the correction arrived after weeks of public anxiety had already established itself in consumer consciousness.

Hotel bookings in Fatih declined by an estimated 10 to 15 percent following the incident. Gürkan Özcan from the Association of Turkish Travel Agencies observed that “events that create a perception of insecurity inevitably influence reservations,” a reality that extended well beyond the initial misattribution period. The damage to consumer confidence proved more durable than the accuracy of the forensic determination.

The Secondary Crisis of Reputation

TÜRES official Rıdvan Turşak reported that sales “still remain about 40 percent below pre-incident levels” weeks after the forensic clarification. The association issued a written statement rejecting the characterization of the entire food and beverage sector as suspect, emphasizing that businesses undergo regular sampling and inspections and that a few noncompliant venues should not define the entire industry. The incident exposed a troubling pattern: initial speculation creates economic damage that persists even after the speculation is definitively disproven.

Compounding Crises and Systemic Vulnerabilities

The Istanbul tragedy did not occur in isolation. A restaurant in the Şişli district where 25 people sought treatment for suspected poisoning was later found to be operating without a license. In Beyoğlu, a 26-year-old engineer suffered severe chemical burns after consuming Turkish coffee prepared with industrial dishwasher detergent instead of water. These unrelated incidents compounded public anxiety and reinforced the perception that Istanbul’s food service sector faced systemic safety problems.

The Lasting Lesson in Crisis Communication

The Istanbul tragedy demonstrates that accuracy in causation determination, while essential, arrives too late to prevent reputational and economic damage when initial speculation fills information vacuums. The forensic evidence cleared the food service sector of responsibility, but weeks of consumer anxiety had already inflicted measurable economic harm. Industry advocates called for policy clarification regarding hotel fumigation safety protocols and communication procedures during emerging crises. The incident highlights the critical importance of rapid, authoritative public communication during emerging health concerns.

Sources:

Hürriyet Daily News – Food Poisoning Fears Grip Istanbul as Spate of Incidents Hits Businesses
CBS News – Suspected Food Poisoning Kills Mother and Kids in Istanbul